The Art of the Stalemate and the Man Who Never Leaves

The Art of the Stalemate and the Man Who Never Leaves

The fluorescent lights of a Jerusalem café hum at three in the morning, casting long, washed-out shadows across tables littered with cold espresso cups and folded newspapers. Outside, the limestone walls of the city hold onto the chill of a Mediterranean night. Inside, the television bolted to the corner wall runs on mute, cycling through electoral maps that look almost identical to the maps from last year, and the year before that.

Deadlock. Don't miss our previous coverage on this related article.

For an outsider watching from across an ocean, a hung parliament looks like a failure of democracy—a stalled engine refusing to turn over. For anyone who has sat in those Jerusalem cafés, watching the ticker crawl across the bottom of the screen while the sun rises over the Judean hills, a stalemate is not an accident. It is a habitat.

According to political analysts and electoral records from Israel’s repeated parliamentary cycles between 2019 and 2022, Benjamin Netanyahu perfected a specific kind of political survival: winning not by securing a decisive mandate, but by ensuring that nobody else could assemble one either. Even when sitting in the opposition benches, or standing at the center of a razor-thin coalition, his gravitational pull dictated the orbit of every party in the Knesset. If you want more about the background here, Al Jazeera offers an in-depth summary.

To understand how a leader wields absolute influence without an absolute majority, you have to stop looking at politics as a race to a finish line. You have to look at it as a game of architectural blocking.

The Architecture of the Veto

Imagine a hypothetical town council of twelve members trying to decide where to build a new road. Four members want it to go north. Four want it to go south. The remaining four refuse to vote for any road at all unless the mayor resigns, though they cannot agree on who should replace him. No road gets built. Yet the person who wanted the status quo preserved gets everything they wanted without ever passing a single bill.

That is the mechanics of the Israeli parliamentary system under proportional representation, where a party needs only 3.25 percent of the national vote to enter the 120-seat Knesset. Because no single party in Israeli history has ever won an outright 61-seat majority on its own, every government is a marriage of convenience.

As historians and constitutional scholars at the Israel Democracy Institute have documented across decades of coalition negotiations, power in such a system rarely belongs to the person with the most votes. It belongs to the person who controls the blocking majority—the magic number of 61 seats needed to prevent a rival from forming a government.

Netanyahu understood this arithmetic earlier and more instinctively than almost any modern peer. During the unprecedented sequence of five elections in less than four years—spanning April 2019 through November 2022—his Likud party frequently fell short of an immediate coalition. Critics repeatedly wrote his political obituary. Headlines across Tel Aviv, London, and Washington declared the end of an era.

They were measuring victory by the wrong metric.

While commentators focused on the seats Likud failed to win, Netanyahu focused on the loyalty of his bloc. By tethering smaller religious and right-wing factions to his leadership, he ensured that any alternative government had to bridge an ideological chasm stretching from secular centrists to hardline nationalists and independent Arab parties.

When that unlikely "change coalition" finally formed in June 2021 under Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid, it held together by a single-seat margin. It was an ideological high-wire act performed in a hurricane.

Inside the Opposition

Walking through the corridors of the Knesset during that year felt like walking through a building where the foundations were quietly being unscrewed from the basement.

In the plenary hall, the acoustics carry every whisper. When Netanyahu moved from the Prime Minister’s leather chair to the Leader of the Opposition’s seat, he did not retreat to write his memoirs. He treated the opposition not as a waiting room, but as a battering ram.

According to parliamentary transcripts and reporting from Israeli outlets like Haaretz and The Times of Israel, Likud lawmakers turned every routine procedural vote into an existential test of coalition survival. Bills that Likud had previously championed—routine extensions of emergency regulations in the West Bank, budget adjustments, infrastructure funding—were suddenly opposed by Netanyahu’s bloc solely to force the fragile government to scramble for votes.

Consider what happens when a government relies on 61 votes out of 120. Every single lawmaker becomes a kingmaker. A single backbencher with a local grievance, a bruised ego, or an ideological hesitation holds the power to bring down the entire cabinet.

By April 2022, when coalition whip Idit Silman abruptly resigned from Bennett’s party, the mathematical inevitability became obvious. Two months later, the government collapsed. Netanyahu had spent a year out of office, yet he had dictated the legislative calendar, dominated the nightly news cycle, and prevented the passing of structural reforms designed to limit a prime minister's term in office.

He had won by not losing.

The Gravity of the Kingmaker

Why does this dynamic hold even when public polling shows deep exhaustion with political gridlock? The answer lies in the human psychology of fear and familiarity—forces that operate far beneath the surface of dry electoral charts.

Take a hypothetical voter—let us call her Rivka, a third-generation shopkeeper in a working-class neighborhood outside Haifa. She does not spend her evenings reading constitutional law journals. She watches the price of groceries climb, listens to air raid sirens test the sky once a month, and remembers the buses exploding on city streets during the Second Intifada in the early 2000s.

For Rivka, politics is not an abstract debate about institutional norms. It is a visceral calculation of risk.

When rivals present themselves as an alternative, Rivka asks a simple question: Have they ever sat in the room when the phone rings at three in the morning?

Netanyahu’s enduring leverage rests heavily on this asymmetric trust. As Israel’s longest-serving prime minister—surpassing founding father David Ben-Gurion’s tenure in 2019—he has occupied the center of the nation’s political imagination for nearly three decades. To his supporters, he is "Mr. Security" and an indispensable statesperson who navigates relationships with Washington, Moscow, and Gulf capitals. To his detractors, he is a polarizing figure whose ongoing corruption trials—on charges of bribery, fraud, and breach of trust, all of which he vehemently denies—have subordinated state institutions to personal survival.

Yet both camps revolve around him.

In Israeli political discourse, parties rarely define themselves solely by economic policy or healthcare reform. For years, the primary dividing line has been binary: Rak Bibi (Only Bibi) versus Rak Lo Bibi (Anyone But Bibi).

Think about what that does to an opposition. When your unifying principle is opposing one man, that man remains the author of your agenda. Every speech you give is a response to his last move. Every alliance you build is shaped by his shadow. Even when he loses an election, he remains the sun around which the solar system spins.

The Machinery of Leverage

Even in scenarios where Netanyahu does not hold the premiership—or governs inside a fractured, crisis-ridden cabinet—his mechanisms of power remain intact through three distinct channels:

  • Party Discipline and Primary Control: Unlike newer Israeli parties created by a single charismatic founder without internal elections, Likud is an established mass party with over a hundred thousand registered members. Over two decades, Netanyahu systematically consolidated influence over the party’s central committee and primary slate. Dissenters who challenged him—figures like Gideon Sa'ar, Moshe Ya'alon, or Avigdor Lieberman—found themselves marginalized and forced to leave Likud to form rival factions, inadvertently splintering the center-right vote while leaving Netanyahu in undisputed command of the original brand.
  • Institutional Influence Through Appointments: Years in office allow a leader to shape the civil service, diplomatic corps, and regulatory bodies. Even during brief stints out of power, alliances cultivated across ministries, municipal governments, and religious councils ensure that implementation of any rival’s policies faces friction at every administrative layer.
  • Coalition Blackmail and Asymmetric Loyalty: Ultra-Orthodox parties like Shas and United Torah Judaism prioritize specific community needs—military draft exemptions for yeshiva students, funding for religious schools, and control over state rabbinate policies. Because Netanyahu consistently delivered on these core demands without lecturing them on secular civic norms, they remained loyal to him even when doing so prolonged political gridlock. Rival coalitions often struggled to match those guarantees without alienating their own secular voters.

It is easy to look at this machinery from the outside and feel a sense of cynical detachment. It is much harder when you live inside the consequences.

There is an exhaustion that settles into the bones of a country when elections become an annual season, like winter rain or summer heat. You see it in the way neighbors stop bringing up politics at Friday night Shabbat dinners, choosing silence over another circular argument about judicial reform, coalition math, or coalition partners. You hear it in the voice of young tech workers in Tel Aviv debating whether to open a bank account in Berlin or Lisbon, not out of disloyalty, but out of a quiet fatigue with permanent uncertainty.

When Crisis Changes the Board

Then came October 7, 2023, and the multi-front war that followed—a rupture that shattered decades of assumptions about deterrence, intelligence, and political invincibility.

In the immediate aftermath of the Hamas attacks, Netanyahu’s approval ratings plummeted in polls conducted by Channel 12 and the Israel Democracy Institute. Many observers assumed that historical precedent—specifically the Agranat Commission following the 1973 Yom Kippur War, which eventually led to Prime Minister Golda Meir’s resignation—meant his political end was a matter of weeks, not years.

Months passed. Then a year. Then two.

Netanyahu remained in office.

How? Through the exact same structural logic that sustained him before the war. By bringing centrist rivals like Benny Gantz into an emergency war cabinet early on, he shared responsibility for crisis management while retaining ultimate executive authority. When Gantz eventually departed the government in June 2024 over disagreements regarding postwar governance in Gaza, Netanyahu still held his core 64-seat right-wing and religious coalition.

None of his coalition partners wanted early elections. Polling consistently showed that an immediate vote would shrink their seat counts and hand power to their rivals. Survival bound them together tighter than ideology ever could.

As long as the coalition stayed intact, protests in the streets of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem—massive, passionate, weekly demonstrations demanding hostage deals and new elections—could not legally force a vote. Under Israel’s Basic Law: The Government, a sitting prime minister cannot be removed mid-term unless 61 Knesset members vote to dissolve parliament or pass a constructive vote of no confidence naming an immediate replacement.

Street pressure is emotional. Knesset math is cold.

The Lesson Beyond One Man

It would be comforting to believe that this phenomenon is uniquely Israeli—a quirk of a small parliament in a volatile region. It isn't.

Across democratic systems from Europe to North America, modern politics increasingly rewards negative partisanship—the ability to make voters fear the alternative more than they demand results from their own side. In polarized environments, a leader does not need to build a consensus to stay relevant. They only need to ensure that the opposition cannot build one either.

When institutions are deadlocked, power migrates away from formal majorities and toward the actors most comfortable operating in chaos. Stability requires compromise, patience, and shared rules. Stalemate requires only discipline and a willingness to wait out the clock.

Walk past the Knesset building in Jerusalem at dusk, when the limestone turns the color of amber and the flags whip against the wind coming off the coastal plain. Inside those chambers, alliances are drafted on napkins, torn up before midnight, and rewritten by dawn.

Governments rise. Coalitions fracture. Pollsters announce historic shifts every Tuesday evening.

And in the center of the room, the chair remains occupied—not because the crowd agrees on where to go, but because nobody else has found a way to move the furniture.

SY

Sophia Young

With a passion for uncovering the truth, Sophia Young has spent years reporting on complex issues across business, technology, and global affairs.