Why Rubio Calling on Cubans to Partner With the CIA Is a Strategic Gift to Havana

Why Rubio Calling on Cubans to Partner With the CIA Is a Strategic Gift to Havana

Washington just handed the Cuban government the single greatest propaganda victory it has enjoyed in a decade.

When Secretary of State Marco Rubio urges ordinary Cubans to partner with the Central Intelligence Agency to bring about "positive change," mainstream foreign policy commentators nod along. They treat it as tough, decisive diplomacy. They frame it as a bold strike at the heart of a failing authoritarian state during a moment of acute economic collapse.

They are completely wrong.

Having spent years analyzing asymmetric statecraft and intelligence blowback across Latin America, I have watched Washington repeat this exact mistake since the Eisenhower administration. Every time an American official publicly invites foreign citizens to collaborate with Langley, the result is never a democratic uprising. The result is an immediate, ironclad justification for the local security apparatus to crush every legitimate dissident on the island.

You cannot liberate a population by painting a target on their backs.

The Anatomy of a Diplomatic Self-Own

To understand why this rhetoric fails, you have to look at the mechanics of authoritarian survival. Regimes like the one in Havana do not survive on popularity. They survive on a monopoly of information and a credible external threat.

When the Cuban economy fractures—when blackouts last eighteen hours, shelves sit empty, and inflation destroys the peso—the blame falls squarely on the Communist Party of Cuba. Domestic anger turns inward. Citizens point fingers at the bureaucrats in Vedado, not at Washington. In that environment, the regime is genuinely vulnerable because it has no scapegoat.

Then comes an American Secretary of State explicitly telling Cubans to work with the CIA.

In a single soundbite, the narrative shifts. Suddenly, the organic, homegrown frustration of a starving population is reframed by state media as a foreign-backed covert operation. Every independent journalist, every neighborhood organizer, and every frustrated worker protesting a power outage is instantly transformed in the eyes of the state from a citizen with a grievance into an asset of a hostile intelligence service.

The Ministry of the Interior does not even need to fabricate evidence anymore. The top diplomat of the United States just provided the smoking gun on live television.

What the Mainstream Coverage Misses About Cuban Counterintelligence

Most pundits evaluating U.S.-Cuba policy operate under a severe delusion about how intelligence work actually functions on the ground in Havana. They imagine a frictionless pipeline where disaffected citizens quietly pass secrets to American handlers, leading cleanly to political reform.

That fantasy ignores sixty years of operational reality.

Cuba’s Dirección de Inteligencia (DI) and its domestic counterpart, the Dirección General de Contrainteligencia (DGCI), are not amateurs. As documented extensively by former CIA counterintelligence officer Brian Latell in his seminal work Castro's Secrets, Havana’s security services built one of the most aggressive, disciplined counterintelligence apparatuses in the world. They successfully penetrated the CIA’s Cuban operations for decades, running double agents so effectively that Langley frequently had no idea which of its assets were genuine and which were reporting straight back to Havana.

Think about what happens when you issue an open, public call for recruitment against a counterintelligence service with that pedigree.

  • Amateur hour begins immediately. Desperate, untrained civilians attempt to make contact without tradecraft, encryption, or operational security.
  • The dragnet tightens. Cuban counterintelligence monitors digital communications, tracks embassy approaches, and sweeps up dozens of innocent or naive individuals before they ever pass a single piece of actionable intelligence.
  • Legitimate civil society gets wiped out. Genuine grassroots movements—like the artists of the San Isidro Movement or the protesters of July 11, 2021—depend entirely on their moral legitimacy as authentic, uncorrupted voices of the Cuban people. Tying them, even indirectly, to the CIA destroys their credibility both domestically and across Latin America.

Real intelligence recruitment happens in the dark. It requires patience, strict compartmentalization, and absolute deniability. Announcing a recruitment drive from a podium at the State Department is the operational equivalent of firing a flare gun before a night raid.

Dismantling the Core Myths of Regime Change Rhetoric

If you search for coverage on U.S.-Cuba relations right now, the conversation revolves around predictable, surface-level questions. Almost every single one of those questions rests on a flawed premise.

Does public U.S. support actually protect Cuban dissidents?

No. It accelerates their imprisonment.

There is a persistent myth in Washington beltway circles that shining a bright spotlight on opposition figures gives them a shield of international protection. In reality, when that spotlight comes attached to the words "CIA partnership," it strips them of protection. Under the Cuban Penal Code, collaborating with a foreign intelligence service carries severe penalties, including decades in prison or capital punishment under treason statutes. By framing resistance as espionage, Washington lowers the political cost for Havana to hand down brutal sentences. Regional neighbors in Latin America and Europe, who might otherwise condemn the jailing of peaceful protesters, routinely go silent when the charges involve verified foreign intelligence tampering.

Is the Cuban government on the verge of collapse anyway?

Collapse is not a policy, and misery does not automatically produce democracy.

Analysts have predicted the imminent fall of the Cuban government every year since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. Yes, the current energy crisis, mass migration, and currency collapse represent the worst structural crisis since the Special Period of the 1990s. Over a million Cubans have fled the island in recent years, draining the country of its working-age population.

Yet an exodus is a pressure release valve for a dictatorship, not a trigger for its overthrow. The people most likely to organize and fight for systemic change are the exact people boarding flights out of José Martí International Airport. Pushing the remaining population toward reckless covert entanglement does not hasten a democratic transition; it ensures that the only organized institutions left standing in a crisis are the military conglomerate GAESA and the state security apparatus.

Why would the Secretary of State say this if it backfires operationally?

Because the target audience is not in Havana. The target audience is in South Florida.

This is the uncomfortable truth that diplomatic correspondents rarely state plainly. U.S. policy toward Cuba is rarely calibrated for outcomes on the island; it is calibrated for domestic political consumption in Miami-Dade County. Aggressive, uncompromising rhetoric plays well to a specific voting bloc that demands maximum confrontation. The tragedy is that domestic political theater in Washington carries lethal consequences for ordinary people living ninety miles away.

The Honest Downsides of Strategic Restraint

To argue against CIA recruitment pitches is not to argue for appeasement. Let us be brutally clear about the trade-offs involved in rejecting covert interventionism.

If Washington steps back from overt regime-change rhetoric and stops dangling intelligence partnerships in front of Cubans, the immediate result will be deeply unsatisfying to anyone demanding fast justice. The Cuban Communist Party will not suddenly hold free elections next Tuesday. Political prisoners will not walk out of Combinado del Este prison overnight. You lose the visceral satisfaction of taking a public swing at a brutal dictatorship.

Furthermore, a quieter, strictly economic and civil-society-focused approach looks weak on cable news. Opponents will inevitably accuse any policymaker who avoids cloak-and-dagger posturing of abandoning the Cuban people or validating an illegitimate regime.

That is the price of seriousness. Foreign policy is not about feeling righteous; it is about achieving measurable results without destroying the people you claim to help.

What Actually Forces Systemic Change in Closed Societies

History offers a clear blueprint for how closed, security-heavy regimes actually erode from within—and it never starts with a public press conference inviting citizens to become spies.

Imagine a scenario where Washington treats the Cuban crisis not as a Cold War intelligence thriller, but as a structural economic vulnerability.

Look at where real power resides in modern Cuba. It does not sit in ideological party committees. It sits in the military-run holding companies that control tourism, remittances, telecommunications, and import-export monopolies. When the U.S. government shifts focus away from cartoonish espionage appeals and targets the financial arteries of the regime's elite, the internal math changes entirely.

  1. Sever the link between the state and the diaspora's wallet. Every policy that forces remittances and travel through military-controlled intermediaries subsidizes the very security forces beating protesters in the streets. Empowering direct, peer-to-peer financial channels and independent private-sector actors (the mipymes that actually operate outside state control) creates an independent economic base that the state cannot easily starve into submission.
  2. Break the information monopoly without weaponizing the audience. Providing unrestricted, untraceable satellite internet access and decentralized mesh networking tools gives Cubans the ability to coordinate among themselves. Notice the critical difference: giving a citizen a tool to talk to their neighbor is empowerment; asking a citizen to report to a CIA case officer is entrapment.
  3. Keep the spotlight strictly on domestic accountability. When Cubans take to the streets—as they did across dozens of cities in July 2021—their power comes from the undeniable truth that their anger is 100% homegrown. Every time Washington inserts its own intelligence agencies into the frame, it steals that agency away from the Cuban people and hands it to the state propagandists.

The Verdict on Washington's Playbook

Real solidarity with the Cuban people requires discipline. It requires understanding that the men and women risking everything to demand basic human rights on the island are patriots fighting for their own country, not foot soldiers in an American intelligence operation.

Calling on them to partner with the CIA does not weaken the regime in Havana. It feeds it. It validates sixty years of state paranoia, hands the secret police a blank check for mass arrests, and turns brave citizens into easy targets.

If Washington actually wants positive change in Cuba, the smartest move the State Department can make tomorrow morning is simple: shut up about the CIA and let the Cuban people own their own revolution.

AJ

Antonio Jones

Antonio Jones is an award-winning writer whose work has appeared in leading publications. Specializes in data-driven journalism and investigative reporting.